AN EXPLORATION

OF THE

SURFACES OF WHITEFLY-INFESTED FUCHSIA LEAVES

 Marina S. Chow

Smith College

 

 

Abstract

Fuchsia plants, valued for their splendid blossoms, are popular indoor and greenhouse plants. When cultivated in such closed conditions, fuchsias are susceptible to whitefly infestation and concomitant fungal and viral infection. This experiment was designed to examine the effects of whitefly infestation on fuchsia plants. Using scanning electron microscopy, the surface morphology of fuchsia leaves were found to be adversely altered by whiteflies, resulting in the reduction of photosynthetic rate and the drying out of the leaves.

 

Introduction

 

Named for the Leonard Fuchs, a sixteenth century botanist and physician, fuchsias (Figures 1 and 2) belong to the order Onagraceae, which includes other herbs and shrubs such as evening primroses and clarkias. Natives to tropical and subtropical regions of Central and South America and to New Zealand and Tahiti, fuchsias have found their way to many cosmopolitan regions around the world. Their beauty, diversity and hardiness make fuchsias popular indoor and garden plants. Indoors and in greenhouses, fuchsias can be cultivated as pot plants or in hanging baskets. They are valued for their ornate, pendulous flowers, which range in shape from tubular to bell and in color, from red and purple to white. The exquisite shape and beauty of the fuchsia flower earned it the popular name "Lady’s Eardrop".

 

 

Figure 1. Fuchsia
Horticultural Photography, Corvallis, Oregon
(Taken from http://www.britannica.com)

 

 

 

Figure 2. Fuchsia Hybrid Marie Nelson (Taken from http://www2.dicom.se/fuchsias/thumbsindex.html)

 

Fuschias are susceptible to whitefly infestation, a common and widespread condition ailing greenhouse and indoor plants. Whiteflies (Figure 3) are primarily tropical insects, but are commonly found in greenhouses, on houseplants and on some garden plants in the North during the summer (Wescott, 1964). They are minute, soft-bodied sucking insects that belong to the family Aleyrodidae of the order Hemiptera (suborder Homoptera). Whiteflies derive their name from the white, waxy abdominal secretion that is used to coat the bodies and wings of adult. They have two pairs of broadly rounded wings, making them appear like white moths. Whiteflies reside in great numbers on the underside of leaves, where they suck the sap of plants, causing wilting, and stunting or even death. The adult whiteflies secrete another substance called honeydew on which mold and fungi can grow. The mold coats the leaf and prevents sunlight from reaching the leaf surface, causing reduced rates of photosynthesis. Mobile adult flies are infamous in international agricultural and horticultural arenas to serve as vectors for the transmission of plant viruses. Whiteflies have been documented to be responsible for transmitting the leaf-curl virus (Borah, 1998), yellow mosaic virus, (Borah, 1995, Borah and Nath, 1995) and the tomato chlorisis virus (Wisler, 1998) among other viral diseases. Thus, whitefly infestation causes substantial damage to plants.

 

Figure 2. Whiteflies adults and eggs on an infested leaf. (Taken from Rodale's Color Handbook of Garden Insects).

 

The diseased fuchsias used in this experiment were adopted from the Lyman Plant House at Smith College during the summer of 1999 as decorative indoor plants. Despite repeated spraying and rinsing with soapy water, whiteflies persisted to infest the leaves. Over the following six months, the fuchsias started to wilt and die. The goal of this experiment was to examine the effects of whitefly infestation on the upper and lower surfaces of the fuchsia leaves through scanning electron microscopy. The experiment allowed the concomitant comparison of the morphology of the upper and lower leaf surfaces, as well as the visualization of the detailed features of whitefly nymphs.

 

 

Materials and Methods

 

Healthy fuchsia (species) leaves were obtained with permission from the Lyman Plant House at Smith College. Diseased leaves were collected from a fuchsia (Hedicote beautu) plant adorning the Calculational Chemistry Laboratory at Smith College. The state of health of fuchsia plants was determined by inspection by the naked eye. Healthy plants had dense and perky green foliage; individual leaves were free of whiteflies and honeydew. Diseased plants were wilted; the underside of their leaves housed large numbers of whiteflies and was coated with little white spots. From each leaf was obtained several 5 mm discs, which were etched using a razor blade for identification purposes. Careful selection was exercised during sampling to ensure that all the specimen discs contained a vein, and if of diseased leaves, exhibited visible evidence of whitefly infestation. 

Dehydration of the specimen discs was performed based on a rapid fixation method developed by Neinhuis et.al. The discs were immersed in anhydrous methanol for one hour. During this period, the methanol was replaced at 20-minute intervals. The specimens were critical point dried in CO2 at 5oC, left overnight to warm to room temperature and mounted on stubs using carbon paint. Of the two specimen discs obtained from the same leaf, one was mounted with its top surface up and the other with its bottom surface up. This allowed both the upper and lower epidermal surfaces of each leaf to be examined separately. A total of eight specimen discs were prepared, three of the lower surface of diseased leaves, three of the upper surface of diseased leaves and one each of the upper and lower surfaces of a healthy leaf. The mounted leaf specimens were coated with gold and palladium and examined using a JEOL JSM 6400 scanning electron microscope operated at an accelerating voltage of 5 kV.

 

 

Results

 

Healthy leaves

Both the upper and lower surfaces were free of whitefly nymphs. The surfaces appeared to be clean, with little debris scattered about. Seen in Figure 4, the upper epidermal cells appear round, turgid. Their arrangement is orderly and in a regular fashion that resembles the roughly hexagonal packing found in fullerene molecules. Numerous stomata, each surrounded by swollen and raised guard cells were observed on the lower surface (Figure 5) but not on the top. The cells of the lower epidermis appear to be of a more irregular shape, possessing lobes that intercalate. Trichomes, hair-like structures that serve a variety of functions such as protection and secretion, were observed to be dispersed randomly both surfaces. There were at least two different types of trichomes found on the fuchsia leaves: one with a smooth, linear shaft and a rounded tip (Figure 6a) and the other with a curved, scaly shaft and a narrow, tapered tip (Figure 7).

Figure 4. Upper epidermis of a healthy fuchsia leaf showing the ordered arrangement of the epidermal cells at 600 x magnification.

Figure 5. Lower surface of a healthy fuchsia leaf. Numerous stomata are surrounded by guard cells. Cells of the lower epidermis are of a more irregular shape than those of the upper epidermis. Magnification 620 x .

 

Figure 6. A trichome on the lower surface of a diseased fuchsia leaf. There is an accumulation of minute, curly particles seen in Figure 19 on the tip and along the otherwise smooth shaft. Magnification 950 x.

 

Figure 7. Two types of trichomes on the upper surface of a healthy leaf. Trichome near the bottom of the micrograph is curved and has a scaly shaft. Magnification 350 x .

 

Diseased leaves

Lower surface: Even at low magnification (~ 70 ´), one could observe up to eight insects on the lower surface of each specimen disc. Upon higher magnification, some of the insects appeared to be generally ovoid and without visible legs or antennae (Figure R4). These specimens were generally 200 m m in length, and not distinctly segmented. The surface of the insect body was seen to be axially symmetrical and contoured. Larger, flatter insects (Figure 9) were also observed on the lower surfaces. The larger insects were approximately 500 m m in length and possessed a border around the edge of their bodies. On closer inspection, the border was seen to be composed of filaments seemingly coated with plates of wax. (Figure 10). Oval insect eggs were present in small numbers (1 – 4 eggs per leaf disc). The eggs had smooth surfaces and were about 200m m long (Figure 11). Figure 12 shows a third form of the whiteflies found on the lower leaf surface. With a length of 900 m m, this was by far the largest insect form found on the fuchsia leaves appeared to be the shell of the whitefly which remained on the leaf after molting. There is a T-shaped opening on the upper surface allowed a glimpse into the interior of the insect form, showing it to be an empty casing. Long filaments emanate from the upper surface of the insect and arranged somewhat symmetrically about the central axis. The insect also appeared to have peripheral short filaments. All three observed insect forms possessed a unique trapezoidal opening on the upper surface of their bodies (Figure 13). Settled in this opening were two highly specialized structures. One is spherical and spiky (distal in Figure 13), and the other is shaped somewhat like a lady’s money purse, with considerably less protrusive surface texture (proximal structure in Figure 13).

Figure 8. Whitefly nymph found on lower surface of a diseased leaf. The body is ovoid, with indistinct segments. Magnification 400 x .

Figure 9. A larger and flatter whitefly nymph that possessed a border around the edge of its body. Magnification 200´ .

Figure 10. The border around the whitefly nymph examined under 3500 x magnification. It appears to be made up filaments coated with plates of wax.

Figure 11. Oval whitefly eggs beside a nymph. The eggs measure ~ 200 m m and have smooth surfaces. Magnification 140 x.

Figure 12. The largest and most developed nymphal form found on the leaves. There are long and short filaments on the surface of the insect body and a T-shaped opening on the upper surface. Magnification 90 x .

Figure 13. Trapezoid opening on the upper surface of the insect body. There are two substructures of very different shapes and textures (see text for description). Magnification 2500 x .

 

 

Upper surface: Fungi are observed to be growing on this surface of the leaves. Figure 14 shows individual fungal hyphae of the mycelium spreading over the plump upper epidermal cells. In the midst of mycelium lies the sporangium, a fairly spherical structure of diameter ~ 20 m m that houses the fungal spores. Upon examination under higher magnification, a similar sporangium was observed to have a porous surface, which is indented at intervals (Figure 15). The elongated spores (~ 7 m m) of the fungus were found widely over the upper surface of the leaf, even getting into the crevices between the epidermal cells (Figure 16). At higher magnification, the surface of these spores appeared to be rippled and what looked to be clefts at lower magnification were more clearly visualized as indents along the length of the spore (Figure 17).

Figure 14. Sporangium and mycelium of fungi growing on the upper surface of a diseased leaf. Magnification 1800 x .

Figure 15. A closer look at a sporangium. The surface appears porous and there are indented clefts situated at intervals around the structure. Magnification 4500 x .

Figure 16. Spores of the fungus on the upper epidermis magnified 1600 x .

Figure 17. The spores at a higher magnification (8500 x ). The surface has a rippled texture.

 

Densely scattered about the upper and lower surfaces were minute rings that measured approximately 3 m m across (Figure 18). These objects were found to be indiscriminately coating all surface features of the specimens, including the insects, trichomes and stomata and can be seen as white specks in many of the micrographs presented in this paper. The rings appeared to be brittle; as broken pieces were abundant (Figure 19).

Figure 18. Minute ring-shaped structures that are found all over the upper and lower surfaces of diseased leaves. Magnification 3000 x .

Figure 19. Ring-shaped structures at 6000 x magnification. The structures were of an identical, well-defined shape.

 


Discussion

 

Upon inspection of the leaf surfaces, reasons for the sickly condition of the infested fuchsia plants became apparent. The wilting of the leaves were caused by whitefly nymphs that were sucking plant sap for nutrition. The insect seen in figure 8 is most probably a crawler soon after hatching from an egg. The crawler is the first mobile stage of the white fly life cycle, moving on its six legs (not visible in the micrographs obtained) to a favorable position on the leaf, where it inserts its beak and begins to feed (Wescott, 1964). After its first molt, the crawler loses its legs and antennae, developing into the second instar observed in figure 9. At this stage, the whitefly nymph is immobile and remains thus, feeding on plant sap and molting to achieve the third instar stage. A subsequent molting results in the fourth instar stage (Figure 12). When the adult is fully formed, it forces its way out of the shell of the fourth instar through the T-shaped opening and flies away. The life cycle of the whitefly is diagrammed in Figure 20.

Figure 20. Diagrammatic representation of the typical lifecycle of a whitefly. (Taken from http://gnv.ifas.ufl.edu/~ent1/software/det_wfly.htm?).

 

At all stages in their lives, the whiteflies secrete honeydew through the trapezoidal opening at the upper surface of their bodies (Figure 13). This honeydew falls on all surfaces that the whiteflies come into contact with and acts as a rich medium on which fungi and mold flourish. This is of great concern because as the mycelium of the fungi (Figure 16) spreads over the upper and lower epidermis of the leaves, they prevent sunlight from reaching the photosynthetic mesophyll cells. Thus, the rate of photosynthesis of the infested fuchsias is substantially reduced, leading to the deteriorating condition of the plants.

Figure 21. Blocked stoma on the underside of a diseased leaf. Magnification 4000 x .

 

The ring structures seen in figures 18 and 19 could also play a role in obstructing the normal function of the fuchsia plant processes. Figure 21 reveal that the minute structures find their way into the stomata, in some cases filling the stoma completely, preventing normal rates of gas exchange. Since the intake of carbon dioxide is essential for the Calvin cycle, blocked stomata eventually leads to reduced rates of biosynthesis in the plants. The identity of these ring-like structures is as yet unclear. My observations lead me to believe that they are either whitefly excrement, or are particles of wax that coat the whiteflies. The highly defined shape and symmetry of these structures strongly suggest that they are not artifacts of sample preparation.

Through the use of scanning electron microscopy, it is evident that whiteflies are detrimental to plants in a number of different ways. Not only do the pests cause infested plants to wilt and die due to their excessive feeding, they also encourage the growth of mould and fungi on the plant surface. The fungi and mold reduce the rate of photosynthesis of the plants by impeding both the light-dependent electron transport chain and the carbon dioxide–dependent Calvin cycle.

 

 

 

 

Acknowledgements

I would like to thank Richard Briggs, John Brady, Judith Wopereis and Graham Kent for their assistance and suggestions.

 

References

Borah,R.K. (1995). Effects of synthetic pyrethroids and organo phosphorous insecticides on the incidence of white fly, Bermisia tabaci (Genn.) and yellow mosaic virus in green gram, Vigna radiata (L.) wilczek. Indian J. Virol. 11, 75-76.

Borah, R.K., P.D. Nath (1995). Evaluation of an insecticide schedule on the incidence of whitefly, Bermisia tabaci (Genn.) and yellow mosaic virus in okra. Indian J. Virol. 11, 65-67.

Borah, R.K., D.K. Bordoloi (1998). Influence of planting time on the incidence of leaf curl virus disease and whitefly population on tomato. Indian J. Virol. 14, 71-73.

Carr, A. (1979). Rodale’s Color Handbook of Garden Insects.

Heywood, V. H., editor (1993). Flowering Plants of the World. Oxford University Press.

Neinhuis, C., and H.G. Edelmann (1996). Methanol as a rapid fixative for the investigation of surfaces by SEM. J. Microsc.148, 14 – 16.

Wescott, C. (1964). The Gardener’s Bug Book 3rd edition. Doubleday & Co., Inc.

Wisler, G.C., R, H. Li, H.-Y. Liu, D.S. Lowry and J.E. Duffus (1998). Tomato cholrosis virus: A new whitefly-transmitted, phloem-limited bipartite chlosterovirus of tomato. Phytopath, 88, 402-409.